Southern Baked Pie - Gainesville

Southern Baked Pie Company is a Bakeries restaurant in Gainesville, GA. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

302 Broad St SE
Gainesville, GA 30501

Phone: +16789712555

Price range: $11-$20

Cuisine: Bakeries

Hours

  • Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday: 10:00–18:00
  • Saturday: 10:00–15:00

Southern Baked Pie - Gainesville Menu

Signature Flavors - Whole & Petite

  • Southwestern Taco — $11.95
    A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies.
  • Signature Buttermilk Pie — $9.95
    This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
  • Caramel Pecan Pie — $9.95
    Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine.
  • Cherry Pie — $35.95
    Bursting with sour cherries and full of flavor, our cherry pies are the perfect combination of both tart and sweet crowned with an old-fashion lattice, all butter crust.
  • Chicken Pot Pie — $11.95
    Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust.
  • Chocolate Chess Pie — $9.95
    A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell!
  • French Coconut Pie — $9.95
    Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
  • Tomato Pie — $11.95
    Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. **Also available in Gluten Free
  • Traditional Apple Pie — $35.95
    Locally grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, all-butter crust.
  • Chicken Ranchero — $11.95
    Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie!
  • Spinach Mushroom Quiche — $11.95
    Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. **Also available in Gluten Free
  • Pot Roast Pie — $11.95
    A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust.
  • Quiche Lorraine — $11.95
    Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, Swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. **Also available in Gluten Free
  • Sugar Cream Celebration Pie — $39.95
    Birthday cake batter flavor in pie… yes, please!! This sweet and silky custard is made with cake batter filling, festive sprinkles, and topped with our signature, buttercream frosting. This pie is perfect for any occasion or celebration, whether it be a birthday, work promotion, anniversary, or “just because”! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight.
  • Vegetable Pot Pie — $11.95
    A medley of peas, carrots, potatoes, and onions, seasoned to perfection. Enjoy a burst of garden-fresh goodness, mixed with a house-made roux, stuffed in a double all-butter crust.

We Cook Wednesdays

  • Pot Roast Pie – Wednesday Family Dinner — $49.95
    Preorder by Tuesday, November 17th at 2pm for pickup Wednesday, November 18th. This hot and ready dinner includes a savory Pot Roast Pie (serves 6-8) paired with a crisp mixed greens salad—the perfect no-prep meal to enjoy around the table. Just swing by on your way home and dinner is done!

Gifts

  • Pie of The Month Club Membership — $99.00
    How it works: 1. Place your order by selecting a 3, 6, or 12 Month membership 2. Select the date and time you'd like to pick up your certificates 3. A member of our team will have your certificates ready at our pickup counter 4. Stop by anytime through the month to redeem your certificate for a sweet pie of your choice
  • Southern Baked: Celebrating Life with Pie Cookbook — $24.95
    A little bit about Amanda Wilbanks and her newest cookbook, Southern Baked: Celebrating Life With Pie GROWING UP, I NEVER THOUGHT I’D BE A PIE BAKER. A COOK, MAYBE, BUT NOT A BAKER. After all, my culinary role models were stellar. Growing up in the South, I was always a hands-on cook, raised in my mother’s and grandmothers’ kitchens, rolling out biscuit dough and stirring aromatic pots over the stove, shelling peas, and canning bounty from our garden. The hustle and bustle of it all was like a second language to me—one that involved touch and taste and smell as much as it did sound or sight. Then, when we all met around the table to enjoy the fruits of our labor, I felt connected to my family on a deeper level. I knew from a young age that food was my favorite way of saying, “I love you.” Using our famous, all-butter crust recipe, I've compiled 12 months of recipes for all of life's special occasions. The recipes in this book are tried-and-true. Tested again and again in my own kitc
  • Georgia Pecans — $13.95
    Chocolate Amaretto Pecans- Farm fresh pecans covered in the most decant Amaretto milk chocolate. A wonderful cocktail snack and a sweet gift to give! Salted and Roasted Pecans- Southern Georgia farm fresh pecans lightly salted and roasted to their peak of flavor. These delicious pecans are roasted in house at our bakery. Our cocktail pecans have been a fan favorite for years and are sure to please.
  • Gourmet Popcorn — $12.00
    Our gourmet popcorn flavors are sure to please! Order as a gift or treat yourself to the decadent flavors of Birthday Cake or Caramel Sea Salt! Each bag contains 1/2lb of gourmet popcorn in a resealable package. The perfect gift and perfect snack! Caramel Sea Salt: Gourmet popcorn Coated in buttery rich caramel and Sprinkled with just a hint of sea salt Birthday Cake: Gourmet popcorn coated in decadent vanilla frosting and sprinkles
  • Hand Poured Candles — $29.95
    “Southern Baked” is a custom blend exclusively for Southern Baked Pie that smells just like walking into our *sweet* pie shops. It is the perfect blend of almond, cream, sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, coconut and tonka bean. “Georgia” is fresh and clean with a citrus base and a hint of peach. "Fraser Fir" is light and fresh and lacks any fake pine scent.

Pie Accessories

  • Pie Cutter — $19.95
    Cutting a uniform pie slice is no easy task, but our perfect pie slicer makes the process easy as pie. Simply slice through your pie and serve a uniform piece to guests every time. This stainless steel cutter features a 10" diameter ring with eight, 2" high blades.
  • Pie Marker — $12.95
    Ensure that when serving pies they look the best they can by using this 8 cut pie marker which makes sure that every piece of pie is a perfect, even size. Our pie marker can also be used to mark the tops of pies, cakes, or cheesecakes to ensure slices are evenly cut. Marks 8 perfect, uniform slices.
  • Insulated Pie Purse — $29.95
    She’s stylish, she’s tough, she’s beautiful…she’s the Pie Purse! This bag has it all and is now at a discounted price of $29.95! -Holds up to 4 pies (or 4 bottles of champagne) -Insulated to keep contents warm or cold -Water resistant -Travels beautifully -Stylish, soft, and durable design

Limited Time Treats

  • Salted Caramel Dutch Apple Pie — $12.00
    A delicious twist on a classic, Dutch apple pie! Granny Smith apples are tossed by hand with warm spices, butter, and house-made caramel, then topped with our signature, Southern Baked, brown sugar oat streusel. And then…. drizzled with even more caramel and a light sprinkling of sea salt.
  • Traditional Pumpkin Pie — $39.95
    Available November 9 - 28th! Our family’s traditional pumpkin pie, resonating with seasonal spices, in our all butter crust.
  • Thanksgiving Dinner Pie-PREORDER for 11/9-11/28 — $39.95
    **LIMITED RELEASE- ORDER FOR PICKUP 11/9-11/28. A holiday feast, baked into our signature all-butter crust. Each layer tells a story starting with our made-from-scratch cranberry chutney from a family recipe, hand-roasted turkey in rich gravy made from its own drippings, a touch of sweet potatoes for balance, and a golden topping of cornbread sausage stuffing. It's crunchy, savory, with hints of celery and onion in every bite. This pie captures all the flavors of Thanksgiving dinner in one unforgettable dish.

Gluten Free Pies

  • Gluten Free Chocolate Chess Pie — $12.00
    One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell!
  • Gluten Free French Coconut Pie — $12.00
    One of our Signature Flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
  • Gluten Free Caramel Pecan Pie — $12.00
    One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine.
  • Gluten Free Quiche Lorraine — $15.00
    One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day.
  • Gluten Free Spinach Mushroom Quiche — $15.00
    One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day.
  • Gluten Free Tomato Pie — $15.00
    One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust.
  • Gluten Free Traditional Apple Pie — $40.00
    Simple yet sophisticated. Locally-grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, handmade all-butter crust. For holidays, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration.

Hand Pies

  • Pumpkin Hand Pies — $4.50
    Your favorite treat now available in the perfect Fall flavor
  • Cherry Hand Pies — $4.50
    Sweet cherry filling in a flaky pastry crust.

Gift Boxes

  • 4 Pack Petite Sweet Pies — $39.80
    Select 4 petite sweet pies! The perfect way to sample our flavors!
  • Southern Supper Box — $119.85
    Your No-Prep Meal Kit! Pick your favorite 3 dinner pies and check 3 meals off your list this month. Pies store in the freezer for up to 6 months and no thawing is required to bake. Pies are 10 inches in diameter and serve 8 - 10 slices.
  • 4 Pack Petite Savory Pies — $48.00
    Switch things up with hearty, filling, single-serve meals! With our 4 pack savory, you don’t have to choose - you can have all of your favorites! Order hot and ready for dinner or order frozen to have on hand for up to 6 months!
  • Sampler Bundle — $43.80
    Enjoy a sampler of our petite dinner and dessert pies. Perfect portions for a date night in or as a way to try our best sellers! Includes 4 petite (5" pies) - 1 Take & Bake Chicken Pot Pie, 1 Take & Bake Pot Roast Pie, 1 Chocolate Chess Pie, & 1 Caramel Pecan Pie.
  • Pie Sampler Box — $105.00
    Delight your taste buds with our Pie Sampler Box. Choose three of your favorite dessert pies, creating a spread that caters to every craving.
  • Gluten-Free Box — $120.00
    Featuring a choice of three delicious gluten-free pies from a selection of seven flavorful options, both savory and sweet. PLEASE NOTE GLUTEN-FREE PIES WILL BE FROZEN AT PICKUP.
  • Grandparent Gift Box — $87.60
    What's a grandparent's favorite treat? Petites! Give the gift of ease, variety, and joy with the Grandparent Gift Box - a delectable assortment for them to stock their freezer & enjoy any time. A petite variety pack of 4 sweet and 4 savory pies - gifting them 4 no-prep, no-waste meals; and 4 guilt-free desserts! They'll think of you every time they take a delicious bite! Sweet Pie 4 Pack: Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, French Coconut Custard, and Signature Buttermilk... Savory Take & Bake Pie 4 Pack: Chicken Pot Pie, Southwestern Taco, Tomato, and Pot Roast Pie
  • New Home Owner Gift Set — $104.90
    This thoughtful box includes your choice of a dinner pie, choice of a dessert, and an exclusive SBP X Heirloomed candle. Whether you're congratulating someone on their new space or settling into your new home, this gift set is the perfect way to add warmth and comfort to any new abode. It's a thoughtful and practical gift that brings the delicious flavors of Southern Baked Pie Company and the cozy ambiance of a candlelit home to life.
  • Deluxe New Home Owner Gift Set — $128.90
    Introducing our Deluxe New Home Owner Gift Set, a delicious collection to celebrate new beginnings! This set includes your choice of a dinner pie, a dessert pie, and choice of quiche, along with an Heirloomed Co. Southern Baked Candle. Whether you're welcoming someone to their new home or treating yourself to a fresh start, this gift set is the perfect blend of comfort and elegance.
  • Deluxe Comfort & Care Package — $125.90
    Introducing our Deluxe Comfort & Care Package, the ultimate gesture of love and thoughtfulness! This includes your choice of 2 dinner pies, choice of a dessert pie, and a box of our Chocolate Chip Cookies made with semi-sweet chocolate chips and mixed with swirls of toffee & slivers of almonds. Whether you're looking to treat yourself or send a heartfelt gift, this package offers a delicious and comforting experience. It's perfect for busy nights when you need a comforting meal or as a thoughtful gift to show someone you care.
  • New Baby Gift Set — $134.85
    Celebrate the joyous arrival of a new baby with the New Baby Gift Set - a thoughtful collection designed to bring comfort and convenience to exhausted new parents. This delightful gift features choice of two savory dinner pies, offering a delicious and easy meal solution during those hectic days. For a sweet treat, one can indulge in their favorite dessert pie that's bursting with flavor. And to make mornings a little easier, a pack of cinnamon rolls for a quick and satisfying breakfast. Give the gift of nourishment and convenience, and let them know you're thinking of them during this special time.
  • Deluxe New Baby Gift Set — $164.80
    Introducing our Deluxe New Baby Gift Set, the ultimate gift for new parents! This gracious gift includes their choice of two comforting dinner pies, choice of a dessert pie, and a pack of cinnamon rolls for sweet mornings. Plus, it comes with the stylish Pie Purse—an insulated cooler bag that's soft, durable, easy to clean, and perfect for on-the-go parents. Give the gift of convenience and style, and make their new journey a little sweeter.
  • Celebration Box — $58.00
    Celebrate all of life's special moments with the new Celebration Box! This delightful set features your choice of a delicious sweet pie, made with the finest ingredients and baked to perfection. Enjoy the added treat of the Chocolate Chip Cookies, made with love & care. And to add a pop of fun to your celebration, indulge in a bag of our festive celebration gourmet popcorn. Whether you're marking a birthday, anniversary, or simply celebrating life, this box makes it easy to help you Celebrate Life with Pie!
  • Amanda's Baking Bag — $101.85
    Discover the joy of pie-making with Amanda's Baking Box, designed for both budding and seasoned bakers. This box includes your choice of one of our signature pies, a convenient pie purse for easy transport, and our beloved cookbook filled with recipes and baking tips. Complete your baking setup with a choice of regular or gluten-free pie crust mix.
  • Turkey Day Pie Sampler — $105.00
    Delight your taste buds with our Pie Sampler Box. Choose three of your favorite dessert pies, creating a spread that caters to every craving.
  • Gluten-Free Gobbler Box — $120.00
    Featuring a choice of three delicious gluten-free pies from a selection of seven flavorful options, both savory and sweet. PLEASE NOTE GLUTEN-FREE PIES MAY BE FROZEN AT PICKUP.
  • Thanksgiving Holiday Hosting Box — $134.85
    Introducing our Holiday Hosting Box – your ticket for hassle-free entertaining this holiday season! This special bundle features a pack of Old-Fashioned Yeast Cinnamon Rolls, your choice of quiche, savory pie, and sweet pie. With this box, you can effortlessly entertain & feed your Holiday guests, freeing you to focus on creating cherished moments with loved ones. Make this holiday season delightful and stress-free, order the Holiday Hosting Box today.
  • Deluxe Grandparent Gift Box — $155.35
    What's a grandparent's favorite treat? Petites! Give the gift of ease, variety, and joy with the Grandparent Gift Box - a delectable assortment for them to stock their freezer & enjoy any time. A petite variety pack of 4 sweet and 4 savory pies, 4 quiche and a pack of cinnamon rolls - gifting them no-prep, no-waste meals; and guilt-free desserts! They'll think of you every time they take a delicious bite! Sweet Pie 4 Pack: Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, French Coconut Custard, and Signature Buttermilk... Savory Take & Bake Pie 4 Pack: Chicken Pot Pie, Southwestern Taco, Tomato, and Pot Roast Pie
  • Comfort & Care Package — $87.60
    Our Comfort & Care Package is the perfect way to show someone you care! This thoughtful package includes a 4-pack of petite savory pies, a 4-pack of petite sweet pies, and a box of our Chocolate Chip Cookies. Whether you're looking to treat yourself or send some love to a friend or family member, this package is sure to bring comfort and joy. It's a delicious and convenient way to indulge in a variety of flavors, making it the ultimate gift of warmth and comfort. Sweet Pie 4 Pack: Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, French Coconut Custard, and Signature Buttermilk... Savory Take & Bake Pie 4 Pack: Chicken Pot Pie, Southwestern Taco, Tomato, and Pot Roast Pie
  • The Hosting Box — $135.80
    Your key to hassle-free hosting and entertaining year-round! This special collection features a pack of Old-Fashioned Yeast Cinnamon Rolls, along with your choice of quiche, savory pie, and sweet pie. With this box, you can effortlessly entertain and satisfy your guests, freeing you to focus on creating cherished moments with loved ones. Make any occasion delightful and stress-free—order the Hosting Box today
  • Breakfast Box — $99.85
    An irresistible, hassle-free feast designed to elevate your mornings. Delight in the divine sweetness of freshly baked Old-Fashioned Cinnamon Rolls, expertly paired with the savory elegance of a classic Quiche Lorraine and the rich goodness of a Spinach & Mushroom Quiche. Transform your weekends with this breakfast spread that brings warmth and flavor to every moment, ensuring a delightful start to your day, no matter the season.

Yeast Cinnamon Rolls

  • Yeast Cinnamon Rolls — $19.95
    Southern Baked Cinnamon rolls are lovingly made the old-fashioned way, a single batch at a time. Our cinnamon rolls are made with yeast and real butter. Light, doughy, and simply delicious – and so good that you will crave more than just one! (1) pack with 8 rolls per pack. Icing included. Rolls are fully cooked. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in the refrigerator before warming.
  • 2 Pack Cinnamon Rolls — $35.00
    Save when you buy a 2-pack of our old-fashioned cinnamon rolls! (2) packs with 8 rolls per pack. Icing included. Rolls are fully cooked. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in the refrigerator before warming.
  • Pumpkin Yeast Cinnamon Rolls — $19.95
    Please select date after 10/1 for pickup Indulge in the irresistible flavors of autumn with our Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls featuring a luxurious Cream Cheese Pumpkin Spice Icing. These delectable rolls are infused with pumpkin spice that's perfectly complemented by a generous swirl of sweet cinnamon. The crowning glory is our velvety Cream Cheese Pumpkin Spice Icing, adding a creamy, sweet and spicy finish that will delight your taste buds. Whether you're starting your day with a warm, comforting breakfast or treating yourself to a cozy dessert, these rolls are a seasonal delight that's sure to please. Elevate your fall experience with the essence of pumpkin and cinnamon, wrapped in every bite. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in the refrigerator before warming.

Beverages

  • Assorted Beverages — $1.50
    Choose from Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Individual Bottled Water or San Pellegrino.

Friday Lunch Special

  • Friday Lunch Special — $13.00
    Let’s Do Lunch (FRIDAY ONLY) Friday lunch just got a whole lot better. Stop by any Southern Baked Pie shop on Fridays from 11 AM to 3 PM and enjoy your choice of a petite savory pie plus a slice of sweet pie for just $13. Want to skip the wait? Order online before 10 AM on Friday and we’ll have it ready for pickup. A warm, comforting lunch and a little something sweet to end the week? Yes, please. Available in stores only on Fridays from 11 AM to 3 PM.