The BlackSheep at Miller Place - 465 New York 25A
The BlackSheep at Miller Place is a Sandwiches restaurant in Miller Place, NY. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.
465 New York 25A
Miller Place, NY 11764
Phone: +16318285554
Cuisine: Sandwiches
Hours
- Sunday: 10:30–18:01
- Monday: 10:30–15:01
- Wednesday, Thursday: 10:30–19:01
- Friday, Saturday: 10:30–20:01
The BlackSheep at Miller Place - 465 New York 25A Menu
Beverage
- Hi-Ball Energy Seltzer — $8.00
- Just Ice Tea-Green Tea — $6.00
Bagels
- Plain Bagel — $2.00
Classic plain bagel, perfect for any spread.
- Everything Bagel — $2.50
Bagel topped with everything seasoning.
- Cinnamon Raisin Bagel — $2.50
Sweet cinnamon and raisin bagel.
- Sesame Bagel — $2.50
Bagel topped with sesame seeds.
- Blueberry Bagel — $2.50
Bagel with blueberries baked in.
Spreads
- Cream Cheese — $1.00
Smooth and creamy classic cream cheese.
- Lox Spread — $1.50
Cream cheese mixed with smoked salmon.
- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese — $1.50
Cream cheese with honey and chopped walnuts.
- Avocado Spread — $2.00
Mashed avocado with a hint of lime.
Salads
- Greek Salad — $6.00
Fresh salad with feta cheese and olives.
- Chicken Caesar Salad — $7.00
Classic Caesar salad with grilled chicken.
Beverages
- Coffee — $2.00
Freshly brewed coffee.
- Iced Coffee — $2.50
Chilled coffee over ice.
- Orange Juice — $3.00
Freshly squeezed orange juice.
- Iced Tea — $2.50
Refreshing iced tea.
- Smoothies — $4.00
Blended fruit smoothies.
- Dr. Pepper — $3.00
Blacksheep Starters
- Aiden's Favorite Pretzel — $15.00
Giant Bavarian pretzel served with beer cheese sauce and spicy mustard
- Gino's Feathered Wing — $14.00
Bone-in wings served with ranch or bleu cheese and celery
- Gramps Roasted Garlic Northern Bean Dip — $12.00
Served with toasted pita, Kalamata olives, roasted peppers, and feta topped with roasted garlic olive oil
- Grandpa Al's Beef Sticks — $16.00
Ginger soy marinated flank steak skewers served with a sesame peanut sauce
- Lilly's Little Pickle — $10.95
Fried pickles with a horseradish cream sauce
- Nacho Average Chip — $10.00
Tortilla chips topped with a 3 cheese blend, pico de gallo, sour cream, and guacamole
The Wooly Bite
- Andrew's Pesto Chicken Sandwich — $15.00
Choice of grilled or fried chicken cutlet on toasted garlic bread with pesto, goat cheese, roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic glaze
- Between the Herd Sandwich — $15.95
Grilled steak to your liking on toasted garlic bread with arugula, mozzarella cheese, fried onions, and a roasted garlic aioli
- Loren's Flying Chick Sandwich — $15.95
Toasted garlic bread, fried chicken thigh topped with coleslaw, pickles, BBQ chips, and a tangy BBQ sauce
- Pat's Blackened Tuna Sandwich — $17.95
Seared ahi tuna, pickled cucumber, mango salsa, and chipotle aioli
- The Blacksheep Burger — $16.95
8 oz burger grilled to your liking, on toasted brioche with blacksheep sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion
- The Squeallin' Sammie — $16.95
Toasted garlic bread, BBQ pulled pork, candied bacon, fried onions, and Cheddar
- The Rebel Belly — $24.00
- The Golden Misfit — $18.00
- Rebel Greens — $22.00
- Kicken Chicken — $18.00
Blacksheep's Garden
- Arugula Rascals — $15.00
Crisp arugula with cherry tomatoes, cucumber, dried cranberries, goat cheese, and candied walnuts with a honey vanilla vinaigrette
- Aunt Kathy's Street Corn — $16.00
Mixed greens, tomato, roasted corn, fried jalapeños, red onion, queso fresco, guacamole, lime crème fraîche, and chipotle ranch dressing
- Salad & Soup Combo — $13.95
- Soup De Jour — $9.00
Soup of the day
- The Abi Wedge — $15.00
Wedge of iceberg with roasted tomatoes, candied bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, soft boiled egg, and bleu cheese dressing
- Blacksheep's Garden - Arugula Salad — $15.00
Crisp arugula with tomato, cucumber, dried cranberry, goat cheese, candied walnut with honey vanilla vinaigrette
- Blacksheep's Garden - Aunt Kathy's Street Corn Salad — $16.00
Masculine mix, tomato, roasted com, fried jalapeños, red onions, guacamole, queso fresco, lime crème freche and a chipotle ranch
- Blacksheep's Garden - Greek Salad — $13.95
Iceberg lettuce, red onion, olives, feta and toasted pita
- Blacksheep's Garden - The Abi Wedge — $15.00
Wedge of iceberg with roasted tomatoes, candied bacon, bleu cheese crumble, soft boiled egg and bleu cheese dressing
- Strawberry Fields — $18.00
Blacksheep's Sides
- Blacksheep's Sides - Avocado — $3.00
- Blacksheep's Sides - Bacon — $5.00
- Blacksheep's Sides - Beer Cheese Sauce — $2.00
- Blacksheep's Sides - Candied Bacon — $7.00
- Blacksheep's Sides - French Fries — $7.00
- Blacksheep's Sides - Fried Onions — $1.50
- Cheese Sauce — $1.50
- Coleslaw — $2.00
- mac n cheee — $9.00
Desserts
- Fatally Yours — $8.95
Flourless chocolate cake with raspberry coulis and whipped cream
- Grandma Laura's Favorite Hash — $8.95
Decadent chocolate, marshmallow, and walnut squares
- Nona's Cookies — $8.95
Fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies served with milk
- Cheesecake — $10.00
- angel food Cake — $10.00
- Fall From The Flock — $12.00
- Tony's TidBits — $10.00
Blacksheep Favorites
- Ashley's Taco Bowl — $12.95
Cilantro lime rice, black beans, shredded cheese, lettuce, pico, guacamole and sour cream
- Braise Your Belly — $16.95
Ginger soy marinated braised pork belly over lemon grass grits topped with pickled vegetable salad with sesame ginger soy glaze
- Dan's Favorite Waffle — $14.95
Savory rosemary thyme waffle with fried chicken thigh with hot honey and powdered sugar
- Louise's Poke Bowl — $17.95
Sushi rice, ahi tuna, cucumber, edamame, wakame, guacamole topped with ginger soy vinaigrette and sesame seeds
- Me-mah's Mac and Cheese — $12.00
Creamy mac and cheese topped with garlic herb crumb and fried onions
- Papa's Fish 'N Chips — $16.95
Beer-battered cod served over french fries with coleslaw and caper lemon aioli and fresh lemon
- Shwarma Chicken — $17.00
- Chicken Quesidilla — $18.00
- Beef Quesidilla — $21.00
- Pulled Pork Quesidilla — $17.00
- Shrimp Quesidilla — $23.00
- Drunkin Pumpkin — $22.00
- Drunken Pumpkin — $22.00
Drinks
- Coke — $3.00
- Diet Coke — $3.00
- Gingerale — $3.00
- Iced Tea — $3.00

- Orange — $3.00
- Powerade — $3.00
- Seltzer — $3.00
- Sprite — $3.00
- Water — $3.00
- Apple Juice — $4.00
Bottled Apple Juice
Sandwiches
- Cousin Joes Chopped Cheese Sandwich — $15.95
Toasted garlic bread, caramelized onions, blacksheep sauce, lettuce, tomato and American cheese. Comes with choice of french fries or a house salad
- Pats Blackened Tuna Sandwich — $17.95
Seared ahi tuna, pickled cucumber, mango salsa, chipotle aioli. Comes with choice of french fries or a house salad
- The Madison Sandwich — $16.95
BBQ sloppy joe, caramelized onion, candied bacon topped with Cheddar cheese. Comes with choice of french fries or a house salad
- Jacobs Fancy Plant — $15.95
- the Fig Whisperer — $21.00
- Rebel Greens — $22.00
- The Golden Misfit — $18.00
- kickin Chicken — $18.00
Little Lambs
- Bash's Favorite Fingers — $10.00
House-made chicken fingers served with choice of BBQ or honey mustard. Comes with french fries or house salad
- Little Lambs - Grilled Cheese — $8.00
Comes with french fries or house salad
- (Kids) Me-mahs Mac N Cheese — $8.00
Creamy mac and cheese topped with garlic herb crumb. Comes with french fries or house salad
- Parker's Burger — $10.00
8 oz burger on toasted brioche with blacksheep sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with french fries or house salad
- Pasta with Butter — $7.00
Comes with french fries or house salad
- Peanut Butter and Jelly — $5.00
Comes with french fries or house salad
Brunch - Blacksheep's Morning Favorites
- Brunch - Blacksheep's Morning Favorites - Good Ole Benny — $14.95
Toasted English muffin, Canadian bacon, poached egg, hollandaise sauce. Served with hash browns and toast
- Brunch - Blacksheep's Morning Favorites - Loren's Huevos Rancheros — $13.95
2 over easy eggs, sautéed onions and peppers topped with enchilada sauce, queso fresco, pico, and avocado. Served with hash browns and toast
- Brunch - Blacksheep's Morning Favorites - Oh, My Taco — $14.95
Fluffy buttermilk pancake shell topped with candied bacon, eggs, pico de gallo, queso fresco, vanilla maple syrup, honey butter, and confectionery sugar. Served with hash browns and toast
- Brunch - Blacksheep's Morning Favorites - The Blacksheep Dream — $12.95
2 eggs cooked any style, candied bacon, choice of cheese topped with vanilla maple syrup and confectionery sugar between belgian waffles. Served with hash browns and toast
- Good Morning, Florentine — $15.95
Toasted English muffin, sautéed spinach, feta, poached egg, beurre rouge sauce. Served with hash browns and toast
- Your Uncle's Avocado — $15.95
Toasted ciabatta, avocado topped with broken burrata, roasted tomato, pesto, arugula and lemon vinaigrette. Served with hash browns and toast
Brunch - Sides
- Brunch - Sides - Bacon — $5.00
- Brunch - Sides - Bagel — $3.50
- Brunch - Sides - Candied Bacon — $7.00
- Brunch - Sides - Eggs — $4.00
2 pieces
- Brunch - Sides - Hash Browns — $4.00
- Brunch - Sides - Sausage — $5.00
- Brunch - Sides - Toast — $3.00
- Lox — $11.00
Brunch - Blacksheep's Favorites
- Andrew's Pesto Chicken — $15.00
Choice of grilled or fried chicken cutlet on toasted garlic bread with pesto, goat cheese, roasted peppers, arugula and balsamic glaze. Comes with choice of house salad or french fries
- Me-Mah's Mac 'N Cheese — $13.00
Creamy mac and cheese topped with garlic herb crumb, fried onions, and scallions
- Pat's Blackened Tuna — $17.95
Seared ahi tuna, pickled cucumber, mango salsa topped with chipotle aioli. Comes with choice of house salad or french fries
Brunch - Cold Fare
- Assorted Bagels — $7.00
- Assorted Breads — $7.00
- Assorted Croissants — $7.00
- Assorted Jelly — $1.50
- Brunch - Cold Fare - Assorted Muffins — $7.00
- Brunch - Cold Fare - Lox Platter — $22.00
House-cured salmon, red onion, capers, tomato, soft-boiled egg
- Brunch - Cold Fare - Yogurt Parfait — $11.00
With granola and fresh berries
- Butter
- Cream Cheese
Brunch - Blacksheep's Fields
- Addy the Greek — $13.95
Iceberg, red onion, tomato, olives, feta and toasted pita with oregano vinaigrette
- Aunt Kathy's Street Corn Salad — $16.00
Masculine, tomato, roasted corn, red onion, fried jalapeño, queso fresco, guacamole, lime crème freche and chipotle ranch
- Walnut Arugula Crunch — $15.00
Crisp arugula, tomato, cucumber, dried cranberries, goat cheese, candied walnuts with a honey vanilla vinaigrette
Brunch - Blacksheep's Endings
- Nona's Chocolate Cookie — $8.95
Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie served with milk
Brunch - Little Lambs
- Abby's Short Stack — $8.00
Golden brown silver dollar buttermilk pancakes topped with vanilla maple syrup, honey butter, and confectionery sugar. Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
- Aunt Megan's French Toast Sticks — $8.00
House-made French toast sticks rolled in cinnamon sugar with vanilla maple syrup and honey butter. Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
- Earnon's Little Eggy — $8.00
2 eggs cooked any style with choice of cheese. Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
- Grilled Cheese — $8.00
Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
- Lexi's Waffle — $8.00
Golden brown Belgian waffle topped with vanilla maple syrup, honey butter, and confectionery sugar. Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
- (Kids) Me-Mahs Mac 'N Cheese — $8.00
Creamy mac and cheese topped with garlic herb crumb. Served with hash browns or french fries and fruit cup
Additional (Dressing / Merch)
- Honey Vanilla Vinaigrette - House Made Dressing (Qt) — $18.00
Quart of House Made Honey Vanilla Vinaigrette
- Ginger Soy Vinaigrette - House Made Dress (QT) — $16.00
Quart of House Made Ginger Soy Vinaigrette
- House Dressing (QT) — $12.00
Quart of House Dressing