Bagel Boss - 555 Montauk Hwy

Bagel Boss is a Bagels restaurant in Bay Shore, NY. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

555 Montauk Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: +16316659820

Price range: under $10

Hours

  • Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday: 05:15–14:45

Bagel Boss - 555 Montauk Hwy Menu

Popular Items

  • 1 Egg On a Roll or Bagel — $6.25
  • 2-Egg On a Roll or Bagel — $7.25
  • Everything Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Plain Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Bakers Dozen Bagels | Breakfast — $32.00
  • Egg Everything Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90

Flag Sandwiches

  • The Chicken Bomber Sandwich — $19.50
    Fried or grilled chicken cutlet on a toasted garlic roll or hero with crispy bacon, melted Cheddar or Mozzarella and Russian dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Maple Glazed Ham Sandwich — $19.50
    Alpine lace Swiss, thinly sliced olives, salt and pepper, and crisp Romaine with choice of dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Pepper Jack Roast Beef Sandwich — $19.50
    Pepper jack cheese, sliced onions, jalapeños, and kicked up ketchup. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Horseradish Roast Beef Sandwich — $19.50
    Monterey Jack cheese, onions, and horseradish ranch dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Classic Chicken Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Choice of cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, and garlic pesto mayonnaise. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Garlic Pesto Buffalo Chicken Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Muenster cheese, thinly sliced cucumbers, shredded lettuce, and garlic pesto mayonnaise. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Everroast Chicken Sandwich — $19.50
    Thinly sliced cucumbers, onions, Feta cheese, and creamy dill dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Everroast Chicken & Muenster Sandwich — $19.50
    Fresh sliced tomatoes and chipotle ranch dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Maple Glazed Turkey Sandwich — $19.50
    Alpine lace Swiss, crisp Romaine lettuce, and sweet and spicy mayonnaise. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Home Baked Turkey Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Alpine lace Swiss, thinly sliced cucumbers, crisp Romaine, salt, pepper, and dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Boss Beef Melt Sandwich — $19.50
    Grilled roast beef with melted fresh Mozzarella or boar's head Cheddar and sautéed onions on thick sliced Texas toast. Grilled with our garlic butter and grate Parmesan cheese. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Buffalo Chicken Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Thinly sliced cucumbers, crisp Romaine, and Bleu cheese dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Rotisserie Chicken Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Provolone cheese, crisp Romaine, tomato, and creamy herb mayonnaise. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Oven Gold Turkey Breast Sandwich — $19.50
    Provolone cheese, thinly sliced onions, spinach, and artichoke dressing. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Monti Cristo Sandwich — $19.50
    Boar's head ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, and garlic pesto mayonnaise. Melted to perfection. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.
  • Bohr's Head Buffalo Chicken Sandwich — $19.50
    Pepper Jack cheese, Bleu cheese dressing, and thinly sliced cucumbers. Served with a 1/4 pound side salad.

Signature Sandwiches

  • 3-Jack Straw Sandwich — $19.50
    Turkey, roast beef, Muenster, lettuce, tomato & onions. Comes with side salad.
  • 18-Don't Go Bacon My Heart Sandwich — $15.50
    2 fist fulls of deep-fried bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo. Comes with side salad.
  • 4-The Main Street Sandwich — $19.50
    Grilled chicken or fried chicken, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato with honey mustard dressing. Comes with side salad.
  • 7-RRS Crash Sandwich — $19.50
    Toasted hero/roll, grilled or fried chicken cutlet, pepperoni, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon & BBQ sauce. Comes with side salad.
  • 10-I Didn't Order That Sandwich — $19.50
    Chicken fingers, bacon, Cheddar cheese, lettuce & ranch dressing. Comes with side salad.
  • 8-The Beach Bum Sandwich — $19.50
    Maple glazed turkey, alpine Swiss, lettuce, tomato & sweet & spicy mayo. Comes with side salad.
  • 9-Zizi Zapper Sandwich — $19.50
    Chicken cutlet, jalapeno, Pepper Jack cheese & chipotle mayo. Comes with side salad.
  • 19-G-B-T Sandwiches — $19.50
    Genoa salami, bacon, sliced oven gold turkey breast, sliced pickles & mayo. Comes with side salad.
  • 1-The Original Boss Sandwich — $19.50
    Salami, pepperoni, ham cappy, Provolone, fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers, olive oil & vinegar. Comes with side salad.
  • 2-The New Boss Sandwich — $19.50
    Sliced chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, mayo & pepper. Comes with side salad.
  • 5-Rud-A-Wakening Sandwich — $19.50
    Fried or grilled chicken breast, bacon, Mozzarella & hot sauce. Comes with side salad.
  • 6-The Loon Sandwich — $19.50
    Turkey, Cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & a drizzle of honey. Comes with side salad.
  • 12-Need To Lay Down Sandwich — $19.50
    French fries, Mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, bacon & BBQ sauce. Comes with side salad.
  • 13-The Whole Barn Yard Sandwich — $19.50
    Roast beef, ham, turkey, chicken breast, American cheese & Swiss. Comes with side salad.
  • 14-What Came First Sandwich — $18.50
    Grilled or fried chicken cutlet, 3 eggs, cheese & bacon. Comes with side salad.
  • 15-Big Mel Sandwich — $15.50
    Ham, Provolone, lettuce, tomato & mayo. Comes with side salad.
  • 16-The Weezie Sandwich — $15.50
    Egg salad, bacon & potato salad. Comes with side salad.
  • 17-Cody Bologna Sandwich — $15.50
    Fried bologna, melted American cheese & mustard. Comes with side salad.
  • 11-Happy Birthday Peter Sandwich — $19.50
    Open-faced sandwich with tuna or chicken salad & melted cheese. Comes with side salad.

Special Sandwiches

  • The Montauk Sandwich — $19.50
    Roast beef with melted Mozzarella and gravy on a toasted garlic bread. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Lighthouse Sandwich — $19.50
    Grilled chicken with melted Cheddar, lettuce, tomato & honey mustard. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The South Shore Sandwich — $19.50
    Chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, and tomato. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Islander Sandwich — $19.50
    Turkey, bacon, melted Cheddar, lettuce, tomato, & Russian dressing. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Godfather Sandwich — $19.50
    Ham cappy, Genoa salami, pepperoni, Provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Philly Sandwich — $19.50
    Roast beef with melted American & grilled onions. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The North Shore Sandwich — $19.50
    Hot pastrami with melted Swiss, onion, lettuce, tomato & Russian dressing. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Reuben Sandwich — $19.50
    Corned beef or pastrami & Swiss with sauerkraut & Russian dressing on hero. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Sag Harbor Sandwich — $19.50
    Hot Virginia ham with melted Muenster, lettuce, & tomato. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Boss Combo Sandwich — $19.50
    Roast beef, turkey, ham, salami, American, lettuce, tomato, & onion. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Beak & Horn Sandwich — $19.50
    Chicken cutlet, roast beef, & melted American. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.
  • The Hampton Sandwich — $19.50
    Hot roast beef, melted Provolone, onions, lettuce, tomato, & Italian dressing. Served with 1/4 pound side salad.

Salads Per Pound

  • Chicken Salad — $9.00
  • Tuna Salad — $9.00
  • Egg Salad — $7.00
  • Veggie Tuna Salad — $11.00
  • Veggie Chicken Salad — $11.00
  • Cran Apple Chicken Salad — $11.00
  • Shrimp Salad | 1/2 lb. — $14.00
  • Whitefish Salad | 1/2 lb. — $16.00
  • Baked Salmon Salad | 1/2 lb. — $16.00
  • Side of Pasta Salad | 1/2 lb. — $6.50
  • Side of Macaroni Salad | 1/2 lb. — $5.00
  • Side of Potato Salad | 1/2 lb. — $5.00
  • Side of Coleslaw | 1/2 lb. — $5.00
  • Side of Cucumber Onion Salad | 1/2 lb. — $6.50
  • Side of Tomato & Mozzarella Salad | 1/2 lb. — $8.50

Fresh Wraps

  • Deluxe Grilled Chicken Wrap — $19.50
    Grilled chicken with sautéed spinach and garlic, melted Mozzarella, and your choice of dressing on a plain or whole wheat wrap.
  • Deluxe Wraps — $19.50
    A wrap with grilled chicken cutlet, fried chicken cutlet or chicken parmesan includes o1/4 pound side salad.

Hot Off the Grill

  • Boss Boss Platter — $19.50
    2 chicken tenders, 3 Mozzarella sticks, French fries.
  • Mozzarella Sticks — $10.00
    Served with marina sauce.
  • French Fries — $8.00
  • Chicken Fingers Deluxe — $20.50
    5 pieces all white meat chicken tenders.
  • Onion Rings — $8.00
  • Kids Meal Deal — $15.50
    Served with French fries.

Bagels

  • Egg Everything Bagel — $2.90
  • Everything Bagel — $2.90
  • Cinnamon Raisin Bagel — $2.90
  • Sesame Bagel — $2.90
  • Whole Wheat Everything Bagel — $2.90
  • Plain Bagel — $2.65
  • Egg Bagel — $2.90
  • Rainbow Bagel — $4.00
  • Salt Bagel — $2.90
  • Poppy Bagel — $2.65
  • Onion Bagel — $2.90
  • Garlic Bagel — $2.90
  • Pumpernickel Bagel — $2.90
  • Honey Whole Wheat Bagel — $2.90

Bakers Dozen Bagels

  • Bakers Dozen Bagels — $32.00

Breakfast | Mains

  • 2-Egg On a Roll or Bagel — $7.25
  • 1 Egg On a Roll or Bagel — $6.25
    Served with ham bacon or sausage.
  • Hungry Man — $18.50
    3 eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a hero.
  • French Toast — $19.50
    Served with butter and syrup.
  • French Toast Sticks — $13.50
    Served with hashbrown.
  • Western Omelette — $16.50
    Served with fries and toast.
  • Hashbrowns — $4.00
  • Pancakes (3) — $17.25
    Served with butter and syrup.
  • Home Fries — $8.00
  • Cheese Omelette — $12.50
    Served with fries and toast.
  • Bagels — $2.65
  • Spanish Omelette — $13.50
    Served with fries and toast.
  • 2-Eggs & Steak — $16.00
  • Home Fries Deluxe — $10.00
    Served with cheese and bacon.
  • Lox & Onion Omelette — $18.25
    Served with toast.
  • Egg & Potato — $9.70
    1 egg.
  • Chocolate Chip Pancakes (3) — $19.50
    Served with butter and syrup.
  • Blueberry Pancakes (3) — $19.50
    Served with butter and syrup.

Breakfast | Bagels

  • Cinnamon Raisin Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Everything Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Sesame Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Whole Wheat Everything Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Egg Everything Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Egg Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Rainbow Bagel | Breakfast — $4.00
  • Garlic Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Poppy Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Plain Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Onion Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Salt Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Pumpernickel Bagel | Breakfast — $2.65
  • Honey Whole Wheat Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90
  • Whole Wheat Sesame Bagel | Breakfast — $2.90

Breakfast | Tubs of Spreads

  • Plain Cream Cheese — $9.00
    16oz.
  • Veggie Cream Cheese — $10.00
  • Scallion Cream Cheese — $10.00
  • Lox Spread — $11.00
    8oz.
  • Garlic Herb Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Strawberry Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Olive Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Bacon Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Nut & Honey Cream Cheese — $10.00
    8oz.
  • Baked Salmon — $16.00
    8oz.
  • Baked Whitefish — $16.00
    8oz.

Breakfast | Bakers Dozen Bagels

  • Bakers Dozen Bagels | Breakfast — $32.00

Drinks

  • Snapple — $5.00
  • Nesquick — $5.00
  • Red Bull — $6.75
  • Coffee — $4.00
  • Juice — $3.75
    10oz.
  • Soda — $5.00
  • Starbucks Frappuccino — $6.75
  • Iced Drinks — $5.75
  • Joe Iced Tea — $5.00