Sugar Hill Creamery - 1642 Lexington Ave

Sugar Hill Creamery is a Coffee restaurant in New York, NY. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

1642 Lexington Ave
New York, NY 10029

Phone: +12126349004

Price range: under $10

Hours

  • Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday: 14:00–22:00

Sugar Hill Creamery - 1642 Lexington Ave Menu

Ice Cream

  • Single Scoop Ice Cream — $5.75
    Single Scoop Ice Cream
  • Double Scoop Ice Cream — $8.00
    Double Scoop Ice Cream
  • Ice Cream Sandwich — $8.75
    Your choice of ice cream sandwiched between two handmade chocolate chip cookies
  • Triple Scoop Ice Cream — $11.25
    Triple Scoop Ice Cream
  • Brownie Sundae — $12.00
    2 scoops of ice cream; choice of brownies or broken cones; choice of chocolate or caramel sauce; handmade whipped cream.

Drinks / Shakes

  • Hot Chocolate — $9.00
    Homemade hot chocolate made with our own vanilla ice cream and dark chocolate. Topped with torched marshmallow fluff
  • Malted Shake — $9.50
    Homemade ice cream blended with milk, cream and malted milk
  • Ice Cream Float — $8.75
    Classic float with crafted soda or cold brew coffee.

Baked Goods

  • Handmade Brownie — $4.00
    Decadent brownie made with 65% Guayaquil chocolate and dark cocoa powder.
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie — $3.00
    Homemade cookie with 65% Guayaquil chocolate chips.
  • Pan-African Rainbow Cookie — $3.00
    A twist of the Italian classic rainbow cookies with layers of Dark Chocolate, Red Velvet and Pistachio cake sandwiched together with raspberry gelee.