Soul & Smoke - 1601 Payne Street
Soul & Smoke is a Barbecue restaurant in Evanston, IL. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.
1601 Payne Street
Evanston, IL 60201
Phone: +18478592732
Price range: $11-$20
Hours
- Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday: 11:00–20:31
- Friday, Saturday: 11:00–21:01
Soul & Smoke - 1601 Payne Street Menu
Popular Items
- BROWN BUTTER CORNBREAD MUFFIN
- PRIME BRISKET DINNER — $32.00
- SIGNATURE MAC + CHEESE
- ROASTED SWEET POTATO — $6.50
- CERTIFIED ANGUS BRISKET
- COLLARD GREENS
CERTIFIED ANGUS BRISKET
- CERTIFIED ANGUS BRISKET

certified angus brisket, trimmed in-house, and smoked low and slow over hickory and cherry woods for deep flavor and tender texture.
Served with house made pickles and your choice of sauce on the side | gluten free.
Please note, brisket is a fatty meat, and lean cuts will still contain fat.
- PRIME BRISKET DINNER — $32.00

Smoked Prime Brisket, Signature Mac + Cheese, Collard Greens, a Cornbread Muffin, and your choice of sauce.
- BRISKET MAC + CHEESE

Signature Mac + Cheese topped with Smoked Prime Brisket and Original BBQ Sauce
- CHOPPED BRISKET SANDWICH + SIDE — $19.00

Chopped Prime Brisket Sandwich with Original BBQ Sauce, Bread & Butter Pickles and Choice of Side.
- SMOKED BEEF RIB — $45.00

Smoked beef rib bone. Each bone has about 1lb of meat on it, is smoked to perfection and served with your choice of sauce on the side.
- PASTRAMI BEEF CHEEK — $28.00

House brined pastrami beef cheek with our mustard-based gold sauce, pickled mustard seeds and micro greens
- "I CALL THE BURNT ENDS" — $16.00

Certified Angus Brisket Burnt Ends served with Housemade Pickles and Original BBQ Sauce. "I Call the Burnt Ends" as seen on Chicago Fire.
SMOKED PULLED PORK
- SMOKED PULLED PORK

Slow-smoked hand pulled pork from heritage-bred, Midwest-raised hogs known for their deep flavor and beautiful marbling. Juicy, tender, and built on barbecue tradition. Sauce served on the side | Gluten Free
- PULLED PORK PO' BOY + SIDE — $16.50

Chef Carter's Smokey BBQ Pulled Pork Po' Boy with J.P. Graziano Mild Giardiniera and Roasted Garlic Aioli served on a French Roll with Choice of Side.
- PULLED PORK MAC + CHEESE

Signature Mac + Cheese topped with Smoked Pulled Pork and Original BBQ Sauce
- PULLED PORK SLIDERS + SIDE — $13.00

Two Smokey BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders topped with bbq sauce and your choice of apple slaw or giardinera. Served with Choice of Side
SMOKED RIBS + RIB TIPS
- SMOKED DUROC RIB TIPS

Rib tips are the "tip" of the spare ribs. They are meaty and flavorful and have more fat and cartilage than the full ribs. Ours are cut from richly marbled, heritage-bred Duroc pork raised in the Midwest, smoked until caramelized and tender, then glazed with our original BBQ sauce. Half pound portion served with apple slaw. Sauce served on the side. Gluten Free
- TIP + LINK COMBO — $22.00

Half Pound Smoked Duroc Rib Tips with Choice of Sauce, and a Loaded Maxwell St Style Link.
- SMOKED SPARE RIBS

Heritage-bred pork spare ribs rubbed with our house spice blend and smoked until tender then finished with a brush of original BBQ sauce for the perfect sweet and smokey bark.
Spare ribs are a St. Louis style rib, with the rib tips still attached- making them extra meaty and flavorful.
1/2 LB is approx 2 Bones, and is served with Apple Slaw, 1 LB is 3-4 Bones.
Choice of sauce served on the side.
*Gluten Free
- SMOKED SPARE RIBS- FULL SLAB — $56.00

Heritage-bred pork spare ribs rubbed with our house spice blend and smoked until tender then finished with a brush of original BBQ sauce for the perfect sweet and smokey bark.
Spare ribs are a St. Louis style rib, with the rib tips still attached- making them extra meaty and flavorful.
Full slab includes 11-13 bones. Choice of sauce served on the side. Gluten Free
SMOKED SAUSAGE + TURKEY
- SMOKED SLICED SAUSAGE — $9.00

Grilled and sliced jalapeno cheddar sausage. Made from heritage-bred, Midwest-raised pork known for its rich marbling and deep flavor. Grilled over charcoal for a smoky finish with just the right kick. Served with your choice of sauce on the side. Gluten Free
- MAXWELL ST STYLE SAUSAGE + SIDE — $15.50

Grilled Jalapeño Cheddar Pork Sausage on a Potato Bun topped with Smoked Onions and Gold Sauce
- TIP + LINK COMBO — $22.00

Half Pound Smoked Duroc Rib Tips with Choice of Sauce, and a Loaded Maxwell St Style Link.
- SMOKED TURKEY BREAST

All natural turkey breast, seasoned and smoked to perfection over hickory and cherry woods. Served with your choice of sauce on the side. (gf)
SHARING
- MEAT SAMPLER — $46.00

Sampler of all of our smoked meats, great for two to share! Smoked Prime Brisket, Smoked Pulled Pork, Duroc Rib Tips, Jalapeño Cheddar Sausage, House-made Pickles and Choice of Sauce.
- SIDES SAMPLER — $23.00

Small size of each: Mac + Cheese, Collard Greens, Red Beans + Rice, Apple Slaw and 1 Cornbread Muffin
- NORTHSHORE SPECIAL — $114.00

1lb Smoked Prime Brisket, 1lb Smoked Pulled Pork, 8oz Apple Slaw, 8oz Bread & Butter Pickles, Family Size Mac & Cheese, 1 Dozen Slider Buns & 1 bottle Original BBQ Sauce
- GREATEST HITS — $154.00

1 Pound Smoked Prime Brisket, 1 Full Slab Spare Ribs, Full Size Shrimp & Grits, Family Size Mac & Cheese, 4 Cornbread Muffins and 1 Bottle of Sauce
Family meals include a 5% discount off of menu prices.
No substitutions
- BRISKET + PORK SLIDER KIT (12 SLIDERS) — $91.00

Make Your Own Sliders:
1lb Smoked Prime Brisket, 1lb Smoked Pulled Pork, Small Apple Slaw, Small Bread & Butter Pickles, 1 Dozen Slider Buns + Choice of Sauce
- PULLED PORK SLIDER KIT (12 SLIDERS) — $73.00

Make Your Own Sliders:
2lbs Pulled Pork, 16oz Apple Slaw, 1 Dozen Slider Buns + Choice of Sauce
- PRIME BRISKET SLIDER KIT (12 SLIDERS) — $107.00

Make Your Own Sliders:
2lbs Smoked Prime Brisket, 16oz Bread & Butter Pickles, 1 Dozen Slider Buns + Choice of Sauce
SOUL FOOD
- SOUTHERN CHOPPED SALAD — $16.50

Arugula, Iceberg, Pickled Green Tomato, Split Peas, Shallot, Avocado, Candied Sunflower Seeds, and a side of Garlic Herb Vinaigrette. Vegan, but contains honey.
- POTATO SALAD DEVILED EGGS — $12.00

microgreens, salt and vinegar potato strings - 4 pcs
- TOMATO POT PIE — $14.00

tomatoes, caramelized onions, garlic, basil, creamy cheddar, duke's, double all-butter pastry crust
- PARMESAN FRIES

parmesan, parsley, roasted garlic aioli
- SMOKEY JOE SANDWICH + SIDE — $12.00

Vegan Sloppy Joe Sandwich made with crumbled TVP in a savory tomato sauce topped with plant based cheddar and housemade pickles, and served on a vegan bun.
Served with Choice of Side. Hint- The chips, pickles and sweet potato with no butter are all vegan side options!
- GRILLED NORWEGIAN SALMON + SIDE — $25.00

Cajun-spiced grilled Norwegian salmon filets with grilled lemon and choice of side.
- SHRIMP & GRITS

Argentinian Red Shrimp and Stone Ground Grits w/ Chicken Andouille Gravy and Chives.
*Pork Free
Voted top 10 best takeout dishes by Chicago Magazine!
- SMOKED CHICKEN GUMBO

Smoked Chicken, Dark Roux, Chicken Andouille Sausage, Carolina Gold Rice + Scallions
*Pork Free
- GRILLED BUTTERMILK WINGS — $17.25

Good Morning America Smokeout BBQ Winner! Buttermilk brined, grilled chicken wings with choice of sauce - chef recommends Alabama white sauce
1 LB order = 7-9 wings
Chicken sourced from Harrison's Poultry Farm
- CHARCOAL GRILLED BURGER — $21.00

american cheese, garlic aioli, gold sauce, housemade pickles, smoked onions, and fries ***Burger is cooked Medium to Medium Well.
SIDES
- SIGNATURE MAC + CHEESE

Crafted with a blend of award-winning Wisconsin cheeses—sharp aged cheddar and a creamy, white cheese with hints of Parmesan. Vegetarian.
***A winning menu item on Good Morning America's BBQ Showdown***
- RED BEANS + RICE

A Louisiana classic: slow-cooked and tender red beans with smoked turkey stock topped with heirloom Carolina Gold Rice and chives.
- COLLARD GREENS

Tender collard greens with smoked turkey, and pot liquor. gf
- DIRTY RICE

Cajun Dirty Rice made with Carolina Gold Rice, House Ground Prime Brisket, Holy Trinity, Chicken Liver and Parsley. Deeply flavorful and packed with umami. Gluten Free
- STONE GROUND GRITS

Creamy Heirloom Stone Ground Grits
(Contains Chicken Stock).
- APPLE SLAW

A bright mix of shredded red and green cabbage, crisp Granny Smith apples, dried cranberries, carrots, and a savory-creamy dressing. Crunchy, tangy, and just a touch sweet—this slaw brings balance to the plate. GF, Vegetarian
- GARLIC MASHED POTATOES

Rich, buttery and creamy mashed Yukon Gold potatoes with roasted garlic and chives. Gluten Free, Vegetarian
- ROASTED SWEET POTATO — $6.50

With Cinnamon Compound Butter
- BROWN BUTTER CORNBREAD MUFFIN

Soft, golden, and rich made with nutty brown butter. —this isn’t your average cornbread. Vegetarian.
- BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES

Crisp and tangy, bread & butter style pickled cucumbers and onions. Vegan, Gluten Free
- ZAPPS CHIPS — $3.00

2oz individual bag
- LOWCOUNTRY KETTLE CHIPS — $3.00

DESSERT
- SLICE SKY HIGH SWEET POTATO PIE — $9.00

A slice of our house-made roasted sweet potato pie. Graham cracker crust & towering toasted meringue.
- WHOLE SKY HIGH SWEET POTATO PIE — $55.00

Roasted sweet potato pie in a graham cracker crust, finished with towering toasted meringue. 10in Pie.
- SLICE GERMAN CHOCOLATE CAKE — $9.00

Dark Chocolate Cake with Coconut Pecan Frosting. Made by Brown Sugar Bakery.
**Contains Nuts**
- SLICE CARAMEL CAKE — $9.00

From our friends at Brown Sugar Bakery. Tender yellow cake with a thick caramel icing.
- CHOCOLATE COVERED POTATO CHIPS — $10.00

Freshly made from our friends at Brown Sugar Bakery. Salty rippled potato chips dunked in chocolate.
- SALTED CARAMEL CHOCOLATES — $6.00

Freshly made from our friends at Brown Sugar Bakery. 4-Pack of chocolate covered caramels with a sprinkle of sea salt
KIDS
- KIDS BRISKET SLIDER + SIDE — $10.00

Smoked Prime Brisket Slider with pickles plus choice of side.
- PORK SLIDER + SIDE — $7.50

1 pulled pork slider with apple slaw plus choice of side
- SIGNATURE MAC + CHEESE

Crafted with a blend of award-winning Wisconsin cheeses—sharp aged cheddar and a creamy, white cheese with hints of Parmesan. Vegetarian.
***A winning menu item on Good Morning America's BBQ Showdown***
- BROWN BUTTER CORNBREAD MUFFIN

Soft, golden, and rich made with nutty brown butter. —this isn’t your average cornbread. Vegetarian.
- APPLE JUICE — $2.50

Honest Kids organic apple juice box
- WHITE MILK — $3.50

8oz Horizon Organic Milk Box
- CHOCOLATE MILK — $3.50

8oz Horizon Organic Chocolate Milk Box
N/A BEVERAGES (EV)
- SPRECHER SODA — $4.00

Fire brewed sodas made at the oldest craft brewery in Milwaukee
- PURE LEAF ICED TEA — $4.00

Your choice of Sweetened or Unsweetened
- ACQUA PANNA BOTTLED WATER — $4.00

Aqua Panna 16.9 oz Bottled Spring Water
- SAN PELLEGRINO — $4.00

Choice of Limonata sparkling lemon beverage (lightly sweetened), Aranciata sparkling orange beverage (lightly sweetened) or sparkling natural mineral water (unsweetened, un-flavored).
- CAN SODA — $3.00

- APPLE JUICE — $2.50

Honest Kids organic apple juice box
- WHITE MILK — $3.50

8oz Horizon Organic Milk Box
- CHOCOLATE MILK — $3.50

8oz Horizon Organic Chocolate Milk Box
- ICED GEORGIA PEACH TEA (TG)

Rare Tea Cellars Peach Rooibos Tea. Your choice of sweet or unsweet.
BEER | SELTZER | SPIRIT FREE (EV)
- SKETCHBOOK BEER FOR THE SOUL — $7.00

Belgian-Style Pale Ale by Sketchbook Brewery, created to pair perfectly with Soul & Smoke BBQ. Won Bronze at the 2023 World Beer Cup for American-Belgo-Style Ale! 16 oz can.
- SKETCHBOOK INSUFFICIENT CLEARANCE — $7.00

Hazy IPA, 16oz Can. This beer has notes of grapefruit, guava, pineapple and mango.
- OLD IRVING BEEZER — $8.00

Citra & Mosaic hopped hazy IPA. 6.9% ABV. 16oz can
- FUNKYTOWN HIP-HOPS AND R&BREW — $8.00

American Pale Ale. 5.5% ABV. Tropical Notes, malty backbone, mango on the finish. The flagship beer from Chicago’s Funkytown Brewery, winner of Sam Adams’ 2023 Brewing & Business Experienceship craft beer competition. 16 oz can.
- MOOR'S KOLSCH — $8.00

Moor’s Kölsch is light and crushable with subtle notes of stone fruit and cracker malt. Aromatic and flavorful with slight pucker yet clean finish. 5.3% ABV, 16oz can
16oz can, 6%abv
COCKTAILS (EV)
- BLACKBERRY BOURBON SOUR (TG) — $14.00

bourbon, lemon, blackberry, smoked demerara. 6oz sealed bottle
- RUM PUNCH (TG) — $14.00

light and dark rums, pineapple, lime, allspice. 6oz sealed bottle
- PRICKLY PEAR MARGARITA (TG) — $14.00

reposado tequila, prickly pear, lime. 6oz sealed bottle
- PRIVATE JET (TG) — $14.00

bourbon, aperol, amaro nonino, lemon. 6oz sealed bottle
- SMOKED PEACH ARNOLD PALMER (TG) — $14.00

bourbon, smoked peach, lemon, georgia peach rooibos and black citron teas. 6oz sealed bottle
WINE (EV)
- BRUT BUBBLES — $12.00

2023 Central Coast Brut Bubbles brings a balanced flavor profile of yellow apples, honeysuckle, and vanilla tart. The notes linger on the palate and a touch of bright acidity makes this wine crisp and refreshing straight from the can or from a glass. 250 mL can
- ROSE — $12.00

2024 Rosé originates from the Central Coast of California. This medium-bodied Rosé is dry in style and is made primarily with Pinot Noir grapes. Beautiful notes of berries, watermelon, and tropical fruits are dominant both aromatically and on the palate, and the wine is rounded out with a crisp and vibrant minerality. An inviting Rosé perfect for year-round enjoyment. 250 mL can
- SAUVIGNON BLANC — $12.00

2024 Sauvignon Blanc originates from sunny Paso Robles, within California’s Central Coast wine region. A vibrant and refreshing wine with pronounced aromas of ripe passion fruit and freshly squeezed grapefruit. The wine is medium bodied with bright acidity that is balanced by a savory minerality on the finish. 250 mL can
- PINOT NOIR — $12.00

2023 Pinot Noir hails from the Central Coast of California. The wine is elegantly balanced with fruit-forward notes of fresh red cherry, coupled with dried cloves and vanilla bean to bring in some spice and boldness to the long finish. Our Pinot Noir is versatile and easy drinking straight from the can or served in your favorite wine glass. 250 mL Can
- MOSCATO- BOTTLE — $45.00

Oxford Landing Riverlife Wake Making Moscato
- BUBBLES- BOTTLE — $45.00

Flores by Catalina
- PINOT GRIS- BOTTLE — $64.00

Maison Noir O.P.P.
- SAUVIGNON BLANC- BOTTLE — $48.00

McBride Sisters Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough
- CHARDONNAY- BOTTLE — $64.00

Les Lunes Chardonnay, Sonoma
- ROSÉ- BOTTLE — $68.00

Summer in a Bottle, Provance
- PINOT NOIR- BOTTLE — $92.00

Brooks Winery Eola-Amity Hills, Willamette Valley
- TEMPERANILLO- BOTTLE — $72.00

Torremoron Tempranillo, Ribena Del Duero
- CABERNET SAUVIGNON- BOTTLE — $72.00

Wade Cellars "Three by Wade" Cabernet Sauvignon
- COTES-DU-RHONE- BOTTLE — $48.00

Andezon 2022 Cotes-du-rhone, France
SAUCES ETC
- ORIGINAL BBQ

Chef Carter's Original BBQ sauce is a Kansas City-style sauce that's bold, thick, tangy, and a little sweet. Made with a complex blend of more than 22 artisanal ingredients, it's the classic choice for any of our smoked meats
- TANGY

Our tart take on the Carolina standard. Chef Carter combines cider vinegar and pineapple juice with a hint of jalapeño, and rounds it out with the sweetness of tomato. This light-bodied sauce is a great choice for pork, and is a go-to for those that want to cut through the fat and add some spice.
- GOLD SAUCE

Chef D'Andre's mustard based sauce has a black pepper and ginger bite and is an excellent choice to accentuate the smokiness of pork, or a perfect match for our smoked sausage
- JERK

A Caribbean inspired sauce with a little kick. Soy-based with pineapple, scallions, thyme, allspice, and a kick from habanero. Great with chicken or rib tips!
- CAJUN BUFFALO

Chef Carter's zesty and lightly spiced take on a classic wing sauce.
- GARLIC HERB VINAIGRETTE- 2 OZ CUP — $1.50

- CINNAMON COMPOUND BUTTER — $1.50

1oz house-made cinnamon compound butter. So good with a cornbread muffin!
- JP GRAZIANO MILD GIARDINARA - 4 OZ CUP — $2.00

- ROASTED GARLIC AIOLI - 3 OZ — $2.50
- SANDWICH BUN

Full Sized Sandwich Bun
- DOZEN SLIDER BUNS — $12.00

1 dozen Martin's potato rolls
- TURANO LONG BUNS (8PK) — $8.00

Martin's Soft Potato Long Buns
MERCH
- ALL BUTTS DESERVE A GOOD RUB T-SHIRT — $27.00

Front of tee has Soul & Smoke logo on the left chest, back says "All Butts Deserve a Good Rub"
- BLACK TRUCKER HAT — $32.00

White Soul & Smoke embroidery on a black trucker hat. Adjustable back
- BRACELET

- BRISKET IS KING T-SHIRT — $27.00
- CAJUN SPICE BLEND — $7.00

You know it from our Shrimp & Grits- now our special Cajun Spice Blend is available bottled for home use! An A+ addition to seafood, poultry and even veggies, just season generously then cook!
- COOKBOOK

- COOLER — $32.00

Cooler collapses flat, so it's easy to store or pack, and especially ideal to keep in your car for grocery store trips.
Cooler measures 18"L x 11.5"W x 11"H.
- FOOD IS LOVE T-SHIRT — $27.00
- HOT SAUCE
- JP GRAZIANO GIARDINERA

- KOOZIE — $4.00

Keep your bevvies cold while repping some Soul & Smoke pride
- LOCAL HONEY

- LOGO PATCH — $5.00

- OG SPICE RUB — $7.00

Chicago-Style BBQ seasoning for Beef, Chicken and Pork.
- PIN

- PRIDE T-SHIRT — $27.00

- RARE TEA CELLAR LOOSE LEAF TEA

- RED TRUCKER HAT — $32.00

Black Soul & Smoke embroidery on a red trucker hat. Adjustable back
- SAUCE & RUB COMBO — $15.00

Kick up your at home grilling with Chef Carter's Signature Spice Rub and BBQ Sauce
- SAUCE BOTTLE
- STICKERS — $1.00
