Sibies Pizza - Amherst

Sibies Pizza is a Pizza restaurant in Amherst, MA. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

481 West Street
Amherst, MA 01002

Phone: +14132566100

Price range: $11-$20

Hours

  • Monday: 15:15–20:00
  • Tuesday, Wednesday: 11:15–20:00
  • Thursday, Friday, Saturday: 11:15–20:45

Sibies Pizza - Amherst Menu

Subs

  • Italian Sub — $9.50
    Slices of ham & hard salami, topped with provolone cheese - you pick the rest!
  • Turkey Sub — $9.50
    Sliced turkey breast - you pick the rest!
  • BLT Sub — $9.50
    Bacon, lettuce & tomato.
  • Hot Sausage Sub — $9.50
    Hot sausage links, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
  • Ham & Cheese Sub — $9.50
    Slices of ham, topped with provolone cheese - you pick the rest!
  • Chicken Parm Sub — $9.50
    Crispy chicken cutlets, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
  • Eggplant Parm Sub — $9.50
    Housemade breaded eggplant, fried and topped with fresh marinara, provolone cheese, toasted.
  • Tennessee Pulled Pork Sub — $10.20
    Homemade slow-roasted pork with BBQ sauce and sautéed onion on a toasted roll.
  • Sibie's Steak & Cheese Sub — $10.20
    Grilled steak, Provolone cheese, sautéed onions & green peppers.
  • Sibie's Cuban Sub — $10.20
    Pulled Pork, Sliced Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles, yellow mustard.
  • Chicken Pesto Sub — $10.20
    Sliced chicken breast, homemade pesto, sautéed onions, mushrooms, green peppers, Provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
  • Veggie Burger Blast Sub — $10.20
    Veggie burger, hot peppers, sautéed onions, mushrooms, green peppers, pickles, tomato, and lettuce.
  • Chicken Caesar Sub — $10.20
    Caesar dressing, sliced chicken breast, lettuce, onion, Provolone cheese.
  • Buffalo Chicken Sub — $10.20
    Spicy chicken, Bleu cheese dressing, Provolone cheese.
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub — $10.20
    Sliced chicken, bacon, Provolone cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato.
  • Meatball Sub — $9.50
    Delicious balls of meat, topped with marinara & provolone cheese - toasted.
  • Tuna Lovers Sub — $10.70
    Fresh made Tuna Salad, and you pick the rest! *If you select no additional sub toppings or cheese, it will just be tuna salad on a fresh roll.

12" Cheese or Custom Pizza

  • 12" Cheese Pizza — $13.75
    Plain cheese pizza cut into 6 slices.
  • 12" Custom Pizza — $13.75
    Select your own toppings.

16" Cheese or Custom Pizza

  • 16" Cheese Pizza — $17.50
    Plain cheese pizza cut into 8 slices. (For the two large cheese special, pick "Two large Cheese Special" - To add toppings, pick "16" Custom Pizza")
  • 16" Custom Pizza — $17.50
    Select your own toppings.
  • Two Large Cheese Special — $25.00
    Our classic two large cheese pizza special. *Requests for additional toppings are politely declined. (No additional toppings allowed)*

Party Size Cheese/Custom Pizza

  • Cheese Party Pizza — $25.75
    16" x 24" sheet pizza, cut into 28 square slices. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Plain cheese pizza.
  • Custom Party Pizza — $25.75
    16" x 24" sheet pizza, cut into 28 square slices. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Select your own toppings.

Apps & Sides

  • Potato Skins — $7.95
    Five to an order, served with a cup of sour cream. Pro tip: great with bacon & cheddar. Vegan option comes with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • Mozzarella Sticks — $6.50
    Six to an order, served with a cup of sauce (these are not breadsticks).
  • Chicken Fingers with Fries — $10.95
    Chicken tenders, fried golden brown and tossed on a bed of french fries.
  • Jalapeno Poppers — $5.00
    Six cheddar stuffed poppers served with a side of honey mustard.
  • French Fries — $4.50
    Perfection.
  • Onion Rings — $4.50
    Rings of onion, breaded and fried.
  • Sampler — $9.50
    Wings, fries, jalapeño poppers, mozzarella sticks. Plus all the sides for dipping (Bleu cheese, Honey Mustard, Marinara).
  • Breadsticks — $5.50
    Topped with, oil & garlic sauce, romano & mozzarella cheese (these are not mozzarella sticks). Served with a side of marinara.
  • Side of Marinara — $1.00
    Red sauce, pizza sauce, marinara...
  • Side of Bleu Cheese — $2.00
    Sibie's homemade Bleu Cheese - goes with just about anything.
  • Side of Wings Sauce — $1.00
    We make our own buffalo sauce... and its extra, extra hot sibling, 1M.
  • Side of Dressing — $1.00
    Get your dressing on.
  • Side of (V) Ranch — $2.00
    The very popular, homemade vegan ranch dressing.
  • Deep River Potato Chips — $2.25
    A single bag of Deep River potato chips.
  • Side of Ranch — $1.00
    Side of (regular) Ranch.

Wings

  • Bone-In Wings — $9.00
    Comes in 6's, with a side of housemade Bleu Cheese.
  • Boneless Wings — $6.95
    Comes in 5's, with a side of Bleu Cheese.

12" Specialty Pizza

  • 12" The Supreme — $23.95
    Pick any 10 toppings - like a boss.
  • 12" Basil & Tomato — $18.25
    Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, Romano.
  • 12" Vegetarian — $18.25
    Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, broccoli.
  • 12" Mediterranean Veg — $18.25
    Spinach, black olive, onion, garlic, oregano, Feta tomato.
  • 12" Spicy Bleu — $18.25
    Bleu cheese, spicy buffalo chicken, onion.
  • 12" BBQ Pulled Pork — $18.25
    Slow roasted pulled pork with Jack Daniel's BBQ sauce, onions and peppers.
  • 12" Mexican — $18.25
    Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeno, black olive, cheddar, Mexican spices.
  • 12" Shepherd's Pie — $18.25
    Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, garlic.
  • 12" Combo — $18.25
    Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper.
  • 12" Ranch — $18.25
    Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, romano cheese.
  • 12" Chicken Taco — $18.25
    Spicy chicken, onions, tomatoes, tortilla chips, sour cream, Cheddar, jalapeno.
  • 12" Greek — $18.25
    Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, feta on spinach crust.
  • 12" Garden Potato — $18.25
    Potato, broccoli and Cheddar on whole wheat crust.
  • 12" Lauri's Favorite — $18.25
    Fresh spinach, broccoli, mushroom, artichoke & tomato, on our original, housemade spinach crust.
  • 12" (V) Combo — $20.75
    Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, w. vegan mozzarella.
  • 12" (V) Southwest — $20.75
    Beefy crumbles, sauteed onion & green pepper, jalapeno, corn, spices, w. vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • 12" (V) Taco — $21.00
    Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeno, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • 12" (V) Mediterranean — $20.75
    Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan feta.
  • 12" (V) Florentine — $20.75
    Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, w. oil & garlic sauce.
  • 12" (V) Basil Tomato — $20.75
    Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan parmesan

16" Specialty Pizza

  • 16" The Supreme — $33.00
    Pick any 10 toppings - like a boss.
  • 16" Basil & Tomato — $24.95
    Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, romano.
  • 16" Vegetarian — $24.95
    Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, broccoli.
  • 16" Mediterranean Veg — $24.95
    Spinach, black olives, onion, garlic, oregano, feta tomato.
  • 16" Spicy Bleu — $24.95
    Bleu cheese, spicy buffalo chicken, onion.
  • 16" BBQ Pulled Pork — $24.95
    Slow roasted pulled pork with Jack Daniel's BBQ sauce, onion and pepper.
  • 16" Mexican — $24.95
    Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeno, black olive, cheddar, Mexican spices.
  • 16" Shepherd's Pie — $24.95
    Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, garlic.
  • 16" Combo — $24.95
    Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper.
  • 16" Ranch — $24.95
    Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, romano cheese.
  • 16" Chicken Taco — $24.95
    Spicy chicken, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, sour cream, cheddar, jalapeno.
  • 16" Greek — $24.95
    Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, feta on spinach crust.
  • 16" Garden Potato — $24.95
    Potato, broccoli and cheddar on whole wheat crust.
  • 16" Lauri's Favorite — $24.95
    Fresh spinach, broccoli, mushroom, artichoke & tomato, on our original, housemade spinach crust.
  • 16" (V) Florentine — $26.95
    Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, w. oil & garlic sauce.
  • 16" (V) Southwest — $26.95
    Beefy crumbles, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, corn, spices, w. vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • 16" (V) Mediterranean — $26.95
    Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan parmesan.
  • 16" (V) Taco — $27.20
    Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeno, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • 16" (V) Combo — $26.95
    Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, w. vegan mozzarella.
  • 16" (V) Basil Tomato — $26.95
    Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan parmesan

Stuffed Breads

  • Broccoli & Cheddar Stuffed Bread — $5.95
    Mozzarella and Provolone stuffed bread.
  • Ham & Cheese Stuffed Bread — $5.95
    Mozzarella and Provolone stuffed bread.
  • Pepperoni Stuffed Bread — $5.95
    Mozzarella and Provolone stuffed bread.
  • Choose 1 Topping Stuffed Bread — $5.95
    Mozzarella and Provolone stuffed bread.

Salads

  • Tossed Salad — $9.75
    Sibie's house salad. Served with your choice of dressing.
  • Greek Salad — $10.25
    Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and feta Served with Greek dressing on the side.
  • Caesar Salad — $9.75
    Romain, onion, homemade crouton Served with Caesar dressing on the side.
  • Spinach Salad — $10.00
    Spinach, Bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.
  • Party Size Tossed Salad — $24.00
    An extra large version of our tossed salad. Serves roughly 7-10 people. All salads are served with choice of dressing. *Temporarily out of garlic bread*
  • Party Size Greek Salad — $25.00
    An extra large version of our Greek salad. Serves roughly 7-10 people. Served with Greek dressing. *Temporarily out of garlic bread*
  • (V) Greek Salad — $11.50
    Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and vegan parmesan. Served with Greek dressing on the side.
  • (V) Spinach Salad — $11.50
    Spinach, vegan Bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.

Calzones

  • Create Your Own Calzone — $9.95
    Choose up to 3 ingredients. All calzones come with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and a side of homemade marinara.
  • Create Two Calzones — $18.50
    Choose up to 3 ingredients. Served with Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese (inside) and a cup of marinara (outside).
  • Jumbo Calzone — $17.95
    This jumbo calzone is made with the dough of a large pizza. Choose up to 3 ingredients. Served with Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese (inside) 3 cups of marinara (outside).
  • Specialty Calzones — $12.95
    Pick your specialty calzone. All calzones come with ricotta and mozzarella cheese (unless vegan) and a side of homemade marinara.
  • Plain Cheese Calzone — $9.25
    A Calzone stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and a side of homemade marinara.

Beverages

  • 12 oz. Cans — $1.75
  • 2 Liter Soda — $3.95
  • 20 oz. Bottles — $2.75

Ice Cream

  • Maple Valley Ice Cream (1 Pint) — $6.00
    Ice Cream from Maple Valley Creamery in Hadley. Flavors vary and sell out - *you can write a second choice in the notes section.
  • Maple Valley Ice Cream (2 Pints) — $11.00
    Ice Cream from Maple Valley Creamery in Hadley. Flavors vary and sell out - *you can write a second choice in the notes section.

Party Size Specialty Pizza

  • Party Supreme — $45.45
    Pick any 10 toppings - like a boss. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Basil & Tomato — $34.45
    Fresh basil, tomato, garlic, Romano. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Vegetarian — $34.45
    Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, and broccoli. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Mediterranean Veg — $34.45
    Spinach, black olives, onion, garlic, oregano, and feta tomato. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Spicy Bleu — $34.45
    Bleu cheese, spicy buffalo chicken, and onion. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party BBQ Pulled Pork — $34.45
    House-made slow-roasted pulled pork with BBQ sauce, onions, and peppers. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Mexican — $34.45
    Hamburger, onion, tomato, jalapeno, black olives, cheddar, Mexican spices. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Shepherd's Pie — $34.45
    Hamburger, potato, corn, cheddar, and garlic. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Combo — $34.45
    Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Ranch — $34.45
    Bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, and romano cheese. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Chicken Taco — $34.45
    Spicy chicken, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, sour cream, cheddar, and jalapeno. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Greek — $34.45
    Spinach, garlic, onion, mushroom, and feta on spinach crust. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party Garden Potato — $34.45
    Potato, broccoli and cheddar on whole wheat crust. Served sheet-style in squares.
  • Party (V) Florentine — $36.95
    Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chicken, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, w. oil & garlic sauce.
  • Party (V) Southwest — $36.95
    Burger bits, sauteed onion & green pepper, jalapeno, corn, spices, w. vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • Party (V) Mediterranean — $36.95
    Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan feta.
  • Party (V) Taco — $37.20
    Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeno, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • Party (V) Combo — $36.95
    Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, w. vegan mozzarella.
  • Party (V) Basil Tomato — $36.95
    Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan parmesan

Gluten Free Pizza

  • 10" GF Cheese Pizza — $12.00
    Plain cheese pizza. *Gluten Free crust is prepared in a kitchen where there are also flour products*
  • 10" GF Custom Pizza — $12.00
    Select your own toppings. *Gluten Free crust is prepared in a kitchen where there are also flour products*

Vegan (ALL)

  • (V) Buffalo Tempeh — $6.95
    Buffalo tempeh served with a side of vegan ranch.
  • (V) Meatball Sub — $10.50
    Vegan meatballs with housemade marinara sauce and vegan mozzarella, toasted.
  • (V) Mediterranean Pizza — $20.75
    Freshly picked baby spinach, kalamata olive, onion, garlic, oregano, tomato, with vegan mozzarella and vegan parmesan.
  • (V) Southwest Pizza — $20.75
    Burger bits, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, corn, spices, w. vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • (V) Chicken Parm Sub — $10.50
    Vegan chicken patty with housemade marinara, sautéed onion, and green pepper, and topped with vegan mozzarella, toasted.
  • (V) Crispy Tofu Bites — $6.75
    Fried* tofu bites covered in your choice of sauce, served with a side of vegan ranch. *Fried in a vegan-only fryer.
  • (V) Taco Pizza — $21.00
    Spicy vegan chick'n, onion, tomato, tortilla chips, jalapeno, with vegan cheddar & sour cream.
  • (V) Greek Salad — $11.50
    Romain, tomato, onion, kalamata olive, and vegan parmesan. Served with Greek dressing on the side.
  • (V) Florentine Pizza — $20.75
    Baby spinach, artichoke, vegan chicken, onion, tomato, vegan mozzarella, w. oil & garlic sauce.
  • Side of (V) Ranch — $2.00
    Sibie's homemade vegan ranch.
  • (V) Spinach Salad — $11.50
    Spinach, vegan Bleu cheese crumbles, onion, mushroom, peppers, and croutons. Your choice of dressing, on the side.
  • (V) Eggplant Parm Sub — $10.50
    Housemade breaded eggplant, fried*, with marinara, sautéed onion, and green pepper, and topped with vegan mozzarella, toasted. *Fried in a vegan-only fryer.
  • (V) Basil Tomato Pizza — $20.75
    Freshly picked basil, tomato, and fresh garlic, with vegan mozzarella & vegan parmesan
  • (V) Combo Pizza — $20.75
    Onion, green pepper, mushroom, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage, and beefy crumbles, w. vegan mozzarella.