Simply Greekalicious - Wantagh

Simply Greekalicious is a Greek restaurant in Wantagh, NY. Order takeout online for pickup or delivery.

1274 Wantagh
Wantagh, NY 11793

Phone: +15166791313

Price range: $11-$20

Hours

  • Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday: 11:30–19:45
  • Thursday, Friday, Saturday: 11:00–19:45

Simply Greekalicious - Wantagh Menu

Appetizers

  • Spinach or Cheese Pie Triangles (4) — $10.95
    Served with tzatziki sauce.
  • Falafel (6) — $9.95
    Vegan. Ground chickpea balls with herbs and spices served with hummus and tahini sauce.
  • Dolmathakia (6) — $8.50
    Vegan. Stuffed grape leaves with rice and herbs.
  • Feta Cheese — $9.95
    Drizzled in EVOO and oregano.
  • Loukaniko — $13.95
    Greek pork sausage with leeks. Served with lemon and tzatziki.
  • Mini Souvlaki (4) — $16.95
    Marinated pork or chicken skewers. Served with pita bread and tzatziki.
  • Keftedakia — $13.95
    Greek seasoned meatballs served with lemon and tzatziki.
  • Fried Calamari — $15.95
    Kalamarakia. Served with lemon and red sauce.
  • Pita Chips — $8.95
    Served with tzatziki sauce or tyrokafteri.
  • Buffalo Wings (6) — $10.95
    Regular, crispy or glazed in our Buffalo sauce. Served with Bleu cheese.
  • Chicken Fingers (5) — $11.95
    Served with honey mustard or BBQ sauce.
  • Mozzarella Sticks (6) — $10.95
  • Greek Sampler — $49.95
    Lamb and beef gyro, chicken doner, loukaniko, marinated pork and chicken cubes, fresh cut fries, served with pita and tzatziki sauce.
  • American Sampler (6) — $40.95
    6 Mozzarella sticks, 6 Buffalo wings, 6 chicken fingers served with fresh cut fries and dipping sauces.
  • Zucchini Sticks — $10.95
    With tzatziki sauce.
  • Grilled Shrimp — $12.95
    With pink sauce.
  • Spanakopita — $9.25
    Spinach pie.
  • Greek Nachos — $17.95
    Pita chips with lamb, beef or chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, Feta, olives, pepperoncini, and tzatziki.
  • Greek Tacos — $11.95
    Chicken, pork or shrimp.
  • Halloumi Sticks — $12.95
    Fried semi-hard Cypriot cheese served with a lemon tahini sauce.
  • Spinach Pie Fritters — $9.95
    Blend of chickpeas, spinach, Feta & herbs served with tzatziki.
  • Kefta Kebob — $15.95
    Seasoned ground beef kebab served with Greek yogurt & red sauce.
  • Saganaki Balls — $10.95
    Crispy fried Greek cheese balls served with pink sauce.
  • Feta Sticks — $10.95
    Fried, breaded Feta cheese sticks w/ honey drizzle.
  • Cheese Quesadilla — $12.95
    With French fries.
  • Chicken Quesadilla — $16.95
    With French fries.
  • Chicken Fingers (3) with French Fries — $12.95
    Served with honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

Dips

  • Tzatziki Dip — $7.95
    Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.
  • Tyrokafteri Dip — $8.95
    Spicy Feta dip. Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.
  • Hummus Dip — $7.95
    Vegan. Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.
  • Dip Combo (3) — $24.95
    Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.
  • Loaded Hummus — $11.95
    Topped with chopped tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, pepperoncini, olives and Feta. Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.

Salads

  • Greek Salad — $10.95
    Romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, peppers, dolma, Kalamata olives and Feta cheese served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette. Served with pita bread.
  • Horiatiki Salad — $12.95
    Traditional Greek salad. Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, Kalamata olives, peppers, and Feta cheese tossed with EVOO and oregano. Served with pita bread.
  • Mixed Greens Salad — $9.95
    Mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, Kalamata olives, and peppers, served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette dressing. Served with pita bread.
  • Caesar Salad — $10.95
    Romaine, croutons, Parmesan cheese tossed in our Caesar dressing. Served with pita bread.
  • Grilled Veggie Salad — $10.95
    Vegan. Our grilled veggies over mesclun and cucumber. Served with pita bread.
  • Halloumi Salad — $14.95
    Mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, peppers, avocado and fried Halloumi cheese served with lemon tahini dressing.

Soups

  • Avgolemono Soup — $7.50
    16 oz. Traditional Greek egg and lemon chicken soup.
  • Lentil Soup — $7.50
    Vegan. 16 oz.
  • Quart of Soup — $14.50
    32 oz.

Sandwiches

  • Lamb or Beef Gyro — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Chicken Doner Gyro — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Pork Souvlaki Sandwich — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Lamb Souvlaki Sandwich — $13.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Loukaniko Sandwich — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki. Sausage.
  • Grilled Shrimp Sandwich — $13.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Falafel Sandwich — $10.95
    Vegan. Served with hummus and tahini.
  • Gyro Combo — $12.95
    Lamb or beef gyro & chicken doner sandwich. Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Keftedakia Sandwich — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki. Meatballs.
  • Skepasti Sandwich — $17.95
    Gyro panini - choice of beef, lamb gyro or chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion, tzatziki, French fries and Mozzarella all pressed between 2 pitas. Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pita — $11.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Crispy Chicken Pita — $10.95
    Served with tomato, onion, and BBQ sauce.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pita — $11.95
    Served with lettuce and Bleu cheese.
  • Kefta Kebab — $13.95
    Seasoned ground beef kebab served w/ L.T.O., Greek yogurt and red sauce. Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.
  • Fillet Mignon Souvlaki — $16.95
    Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki. Meatballs.

Skewers

  • Pork Souvlaki Skewers — $6.25
    Served with pita bread.
  • Chicken Souvlaki Skewers — $6.25
    Served with pita bread.
  • Lamb Souvlaki Skewers — $8.50
    Served with pita bread.
  • Fillet Mignon Skewers — $9.95
    Served with pita bread.
  • Crispy Chicken Skewers — $6.50
    Served with pita bread.

Burgers

  • Classic Burger — $9.95
    Lettuce, tomato and pickle.
  • Cheeseburger — $10.95
    Choice of American or Mozzarella.
  • Greek Burger — $10.95
    Feta, tomato and onion.
  • Grilled Chicken Burger — $9.95
  • Philly Steak Burger — $10.95
    Peppers, onions and American cheese.
  • Falafel Smash Burger — $9.50
    Vegan. Lettuce, tomato, pickle and hummus.
  • Crispy Chicken Sandwich — $9.50
    Lettuce, tomato, pickle and our signature yellow sauce.

Wraps

  • Gyro Lovers Wrap — $11.95
    Gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and tzatziki.
  • Athenian Wrap — $11.95
    Chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onions, and tzatziki.
  • Greek Salad Wrap — $10.95
    Our Greek salad all wrapped up.
  • Falafel Wrap — $10.95
    Lettuce, tomato, onion, hummus, and tahini.
  • Mediterranean Wrap — $12.95
    Grilled chicken, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, olives, Feta cheese, and our house vinaigrette.
  • Grilled Shrimp Wrap — $12.95
    Grilled shrimp, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, avocado, and pink sauce.
  • Chicken Caesar Wrap — $11.95
    Romaine, Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing, and grilled chicken.
  • Chicken Club Wrap — $12.95
    Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and pink sauce.
  • Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap — $11.95
    Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.
  • Steakhouse Wrap — $16.95
    Skirt steak, Romaine, tomato, red onion, and Bleu cheese dressing.
  • Philly Steak Wrap — $12.95
    Our Philly steak all wrapped up.
  • Grilled Veggie Wrap — $10.95
    Grilled veggies with lettuce.
  • Grecian Wrap — $11.95
    Chicken souvlaki, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and tzatziki.
  • Greek Burrito — $12.95
    Chicken, spicy Feta, rice, avocado, tomato and onion.
  • Halloumi Wrap — $11.95
    Halloumi cheese, mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, avocado and lemon tahini sauce.

Sides

  • French Fries — $6.50
    Vegan.
  • Greek Fries — $9.95
    With crumbled Feta and oregano.
  • Curly Fries — $7.50
  • Onion Rings — $7.50
  • Lemon Potatoes — $8.50
  • Rice — $6.50
  • Lamb & Beef Gyro — $10.95
    Shaved spiced lamb and beef served with tzatziki.
  • Gyro Fries — $14.95
    With gyro and crumbled Feta.
  • Grilled Chicken — $10.95
    Marinated by Greekalicious.
  • Cheese Fries — $8.50
  • Bacon Cheese Fries — $11.95
  • Philly Steak Fries — $15.95
  • Grilled Veggies — $8.50
    Vegan.
  • Greek Salad Jr. — $7.95
  • Sweet Potato Fries — $7.50
  • Chicken Doner — $10.95
    Marinated shaved chicken served with tzatziki.

Desserts

  • Baklava — $5.95
  • Rice Pudding — $4.95
  • Greek Zeppoles — $5.95
    Loukoumades.
  • Greek Yogurt — $6.95
  • Fried Oreos (5) — $7.95
  • Galaktoboureko — $7.95
    Custard pie.
  • Revani — $7.95
    Semolina cake.
  • Baklava Cheesecake — $7.95
  • Portokalopita — $6.95
    Greek orange cake.
  • Chocolate Temptation — $5.95
  • Nut Rolls — $5.95

Kids Menu

  • Kid's Chicken Tenders (3) & Fries — $12.95
  • Kid's Hamburger & Fries — $12.95
  • Kid's Mozzarella Sticks (4) & Fries — $12.95
  • Kid's Platter — $12.95
    Choice of lamb/beef, chicken doner, pork or chicken souvlaki. Served with fries, pita and tzatziki sauce
  • Kid's Cheese Quesadilla & Fries — $12.95

Beverages

  • Canned Soda — $1.75
  • 20 oz. Bottled Soda — $3.50
  • Classic Glass Bottles — $3.50
  • Snapple — $3.50
  • Bottled Water — $1.75
  • 1.25 Liter Soda — $4.75
  • Coffee — $2.00
  • Greek Frappe — $4.95
  • Stewarts — $3.50
  • Iced Coffee — $4.50
  • Greek Specialty Drink — $3.50
  • Fresh Lemonade — $4.00
  • Sour Cherry Lemonade — $5.00

Family Combos

  • Souvlaki Feast Combo — $79.95
    10 pork or chicken skewers, pita bread, tzatziki, fresh cut fries, Greek salad, and 1.25 liter soda.
  • Gyro Lovers Combo — $64.95
    Choice of 4 gyro sandwiches (lamb, beef or chicken doner), fresh cut fries, Greek salad, and 1.25 liter soda.
  • Family Style Combo — $109.95
    1/2 tray lamb, beef and chicken gyro, 1/2 tray rice or French fries, 1/2 tray Greek salad, pita bread, tzatziki and (12) loukoumades with honey cinnamon.

Platters

  • Lamb or Beef Gyro Platter — $20.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Chicken Doner Gyro Platter — $20.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Pork Souvlaki Platter — $20.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Chicken Souvlaki Platter — $20.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Lamb Souvlaki Platter — $25.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Grilled Chicken Platter — $20.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Loukaniko Platter — $20.95
    Sausage. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Keftedakia Platter — $20.95
    Meatballs. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Grilled Shrimp Platter — $24.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Falafel Platter — $19.95
    Vegan. Served with hummus and tahini. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Gyro Combo Platter — $21.75
    Lamb or beef gyro & chicken doner combo. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Souvlaki Combo Platter — $20.95
    Pork & chicken. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Surf & Turf Platter — $28.95
    Skirt steak and grilled shrimp. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Spinach Pie Combo Platter — $19.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Moussaka Platter — $22.95
    All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Kefta Kebab Platter — $25.95
    Seasoned ground beef kebab served w/ L.T.O, Greek yogurt and red sauce. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.
  • Fllet Mignon Souvlaki Platter — $28.95
    Meatballs. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup with tzatziki and pita bread.

Greek Box

  • Lamb or Beef Gyro Box — $16.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.
  • Chicken Doner Box — $16.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.
  • Souvlaki Box — $16.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.
  • Falafel Box — $15.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.
  • Crispy Chicken Box — $15.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.
  • Kefta Kebob Box — $17.95
    All Greek boxes come with lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, Feta, pita and tzatziki. Choice of rice or French fries.

Extras.

  • Small Tzatziki — $1.25
  • Small Pink Sauce — $1.25
  • Small Red Sauce — $1.25
  • Small Yellow Sauce — $1.25
  • Small Lemon Tahini — $1.25
  • Small Chipotle Tzatziki Crema — $1.25
  • Small Spicy Feta — $2.50
  • Small Hummus — $1.25
  • Pita Bread — $1.25
  • Whole Wheat Pita Bread — $1.50

Bowls

  • #1 Mediterranean Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, romaine lettuce, chopped tomato, cucumber, red onion, green peppers, olives, pepperoncini, Feta, grilled chicken, tzatziki & pita bread.
  • #2 Gyro Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, shredded lettuce, chopped tomato, cucumber, onion, lamb, beef or chicken gyro, tzatziki & pita bread.
  • #3 California Greek Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, romaine lettuce, chopped tomato, cucumber, red onion, avocado, hard boiled egg, bacon, grilled chicken, pink sauce & pita bread.
  • #4 Greek Comfort Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, chopped tomato, cucumber, red onion, pepper, olive, pepperoncini, feta, lemon potato, chicken or pork souvlaki, vinaigrette dressing & pita bread.
  • #5 My Big Fat Greek Bowl — $14.95
    Fries, lamb, beef or chicken gyro, chopped tomato, red onion, pepper, cucumber, Feta sticks, spicy Feta, tzatziki & pita bread.
  • #6 The Halloumi Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, mesclun greens, chopped tomato, cucumber, peppers, olives, onions, avocado, Halloumi cheese, lemon tahini dressing & pita bread.
  • #7 Greek Burrito Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, grilled chicken, Greek pico de gallo, smashed avocado, spicy Feta, chipotle tzatziki crema & pita bread.
  • #8 El Greco Loco — $14.95
    Rice, chipotle chicken or pork, Greek pico de gallo, smashed avocado, crumbled Feta, Cotija cheese, chipotle tzatziki crema & pita bread.
  • #9 Buffalo Blue Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, iceberg, shredded carrot, celery, Buffalo chicken gyro, Blue cheese & pita bread.
  • #10 the C.B.R. Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, iceberg, lettuce, chopped tomato, cucumber, red onion, bacon, crispy chicken, ranch dressing & pita bread.
  • #11 The Vegetarian Bowl — $14.95
    Vegan. Rice, mesclun greens, chickpeas, chopped tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, pepperoncini, olives, falafel, lemon tahini, & pita bread.
  • #12 Grilled Shrimp Bowl — $14.95
    Rice, romaine lettuce, chopped tomato, cucumber, green pepper, onion, avocado, grilled shrimp, pink sauce & pita bread.